Three young women (Tina Krause, Pamela Sutch, Vanessa Carlton) decide to watch the movie "The Little World of Wilbur" in which a man is shrunken down in size and kept as a "pet" for the woman's (Dawn Murphy) amusement. After seeing the movie, each girl has a dream about how she would shrink her friends down and get even with them for previous slights. A detective (Dean Paul) also becomes involved. What fate awaits them all?
Penny (Dawn Murphy), the coach's daughter from the original Dead In The Pool, faces her greatest challenge. After being viciously beaten, she's left paralyzed and in a wheel chair. Experimental treatments may help her regain her ability to walk, but at what cost? She begins to have nightmares about killing the people responsible for her plight. But then she learns they aren't really nightmares at all when each of the victims turns up dead, drowned by an unknown killer. But is the killer Penny or her rival, Susan (Vanessa Carlton) Pierce, the person responsible for Penny's injuries? Learn the truth in Dead In The Pool 2.