Hidden deep within the walls of Jess Bradford's mansion lies the evidence that will exonerate her former boyfriend Peter Smythe and expose the real 1974 Bedford killers. Picking up immediately where chapter 1 ended, Sam and her grandmother, now trapped and alone, must fight back against the clutches of Christmas evil before they're swallowed by its darkness.
Single mom and chef Lilah sees her dreams for the future falling apart when arrogant tech innovator Charlie buys her beloved family restaurant with plans to turn it into a buzzy dining experience. Instead of “reinventing lasagna” for Charlie’s new menu, Lilah puts everything she has into showing Charlie the meaning of community and tradition in their little corner of Brooklyn. Sparks fly between them as they appreciate the present and realize their future dreams are with each other.
Nearly fifty years after the events of "Black Christmas," Sam, Jess Bradford's granddaughter, is spending Christmas Eve at her grandmother's old country mansion with two girlfriends. Stalked by a sinister evil that has been lurking in the shadows for years, Sam is about to come face to face with the man who terrorized her grandmother's sorority in 1974.